2025-04-04T10:01:27.000Z

---

Nancy Pelosi, a significant figure in the Democratic Party and a seasoned political player, has spent an impressive 38 years serving in Congress, including eight years as the Speaker of the House of Representatives. As the first woman to hold this prestigious position, Pelosi has navigated the complex and often tumultuous waters of American politics. However, a growing number of voices within her party, including Saikat Chakrabarti, a former chief of staff to progressive congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, are calling for a drastic change in leadership and strategy.

Chakrabarti, who is 37 years old, has expressed deep dissatisfaction with Pelosi’s leadership style, asserting that she has become a symbol of the stagnation that plagues a Democratic Party out of touch with the realities faced by everyday Americans. He has taken a bold step by launching a primary challenge against her, seeking to take her congressional seat and potentially reshape the party’s direction. “People don’t like the Democratic Party now even more than Donald Trump,” Chakrabarti declared, echoing a sentiment of urgency for a “full takeover of the party” by new, progressive voices.

Chakrabarti's insurgency reflects a broader civil war within the Democratic Party, especially after the disappointing defeat of Kamala Harris in the recent presidential election. This loss resulted in the Republicans regaining control of the House, Senate, and the White House, and has left many Democrats feeling disillusioned and directionless.

The discontent within the party is palpable, as recent polling by NBC has shown a significant decline in approval ratings, with only 27 percent of Americans expressing a positive view of the Democratic Party. This figure marks the lowest approval rating for the party since the survey began in 1990. Jeff Horwitt, a researcher at Hart Research, referred to this period as a “nadir for the party,” highlighting a glaring leadership vacuum that many party members are eager to fill.

In conversations with over a dozen senior Democrats, the overwhelming sentiment is one of urgency mixed with fear. The party is embroiled in factional fighting, struggling to determine the most effective way to respond to Trump’s aggressive policy agenda, which includes significant changes in federal agency structures and imposing harsh tariffs on various trading partners.

Chuck Schumer, the Senate’s Democratic leader, has faced significant backlash from a number of House members and liberal advocacy groups after he supported a Republican-led budget bill earlier this month. This decision, seen by some as a compromise to avoid a federal government shutdown, has intensified calls for his resignation.

At the grassroots level, tens of thousands of frustrated voters have rallied around Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Bernie Sanders, both of whom have been vocal critics not only of Trump but also of the Democratic establishment. “I’ve never seen anger at the political class this strong,” remarked California Representative Ro Khanna, pointing to a widespread frustration among constituents regarding the party's inability to effectively challenge Trump. “There is anger at Democrats for our country being in this situation where we let Donald Trump win — and for not putting up a bold and tough enough fight.”

Khanna's assertion that the party has been “spineless” in confronting “corporate greed” that has eroded the working class resonates with many voters who feel abandoned. The political landscape is shifting, as Trump’s surprising victory in November showcased his ability to appeal to traditionally Democratic demographics, including younger voters, Black voters, and Latino voters, who have increasingly leaned toward the Republican side.

Brendan Boyle, a congressman from Pennsylvania, emphasized the need for reflection within the party, questioning why the Democrats are struggling to connect culturally with a considerable portion of the American population. The internal divisions within the party are complex and multi-faceted: Should the Democrats shift towards a more centrist viewpoint, or should they embrace a more progressive stance? Should they fight Republicans at every turn, or seek out avenues for compromise? These questions are at the forefront of discussions among party leaders.

It is important to note that this rift is not merely a battle between progressives and moderates; rather, it involves a strategic and tactical debate regarding how best to engage with the Trump administration. According to Kris Balderston, a former deputy chief of staff to Hillary Clinton, the discussions revolve around the level of conflict the party is willing to engage in.

The base of the Democratic Party appears to be increasingly eager for a fight, with a recent survey indicating that 65 percent of Democratic voters want their leaders to adopt a more confrontational stance against Trump, in stark contrast to previous years when many favored compromise. Ocasio-Cortez has not shied away from voicing her concerns, accusing Schumer of “betrayal” for his recent actions and has even suggested the possibility of challenging him for his Senate seat.

On the other hand, there are moderates within the party, such as Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman, who have criticized what they perceive as “extreme voices” demanding new leadership. They advocate for a more nuanced approach that considers the opinions of voters in swing districts rather than only catering to the liberal enclaves. “We have this perception of being this elitist party that talks down to America,” Moulton remarked, warning that such an attitude could further alienate potential supporters.

The political landscape is not entirely bleak for the Democrats. In recent elections, they have made inroads into traditionally Republican strongholds, as evidenced by a Democratic judge’s victory in Wisconsin against a candidate supported by Trump and Elon Musk. Suzan DelBene, who leads the Democratic congressional campaign committee, has emphasized that focusing on “kitchen table issues” has resulted in significant electoral gains for the party, suggesting that this approach will continue to be pivotal heading into the midterms.

However, the call for a radical reevaluation of what the party stands for is becoming increasingly urgent among many within the party. Moulton’s statement underscored a widespread belief that there is a lack of accountability among establishment Democrats. “We lost to a convicted felon. This should have been a Democratic clean-up across the board,” he noted, highlighting the critical need for introspection and change as the Democratic Party approaches the 2024 election cycle.