India and Pakistan Exchange Accusations Shortly After Ceasefire Agreement










2025-05-10T20:22:32Z

ISLAMABAD — In a recent development that underscores the fragile nature of peace between India and Pakistan, both nations reached a ceasefire agreement on Saturday following U.S.-led negotiations aimed at resolving escalating tensions that have threatened regional stability. However, merely hours after the announcement, both countries accused each other of violating the ceasefire, indicating that the situation remains precarious.
This ceasefire was anticipated to bring an end to weeks of heightened military conflict, characterized by missile launches and drone strikes. The recent hostilities were ignited by a tragic attack last month in which gunmen killed a group of tourists in India, an act that India has attributed to Pakistan, a claim that Pakistan vehemently denies.
On Saturday evening, Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri expressed deep concerns at a news conference held in New Delhi, stating, "there had been repeated violations of the understanding arrived between the two countries." Misri specifically accused Pakistan of breaching the ceasefire agreement, which was meant to foster a moment of respite from the violence. He urged Pakistan to take responsible steps to rectify the situation and emphasized that the Indian army was taking retaliatory measures against what he described as a "border intrusion."
Meanwhile, in Islamabad, the Pakistani Foreign Ministry countered these accusations, asserting that it was Indian forces that initiated the ceasefire violations. The ministry reiterated Pakistan's commitment to the agreement, asserting that its military was managing the situation with restraint and responsibility. They stated, "We believe that any issues in the smooth implementation of the ceasefire should be addressed through communication at appropriate levels," highlighting the need for dialogue rather than escalation.
The announcement of the ceasefire was first made by U.S. President Donald Trump, who took to his Truth Social platform to congratulate both nations for what he termed their "Common Sense and Great Intelligence" in agreeing to the truce. His comments reflect a significant international interest in stabilizing the relationship between these two nuclear-armed countries, which have a long history of conflict.
Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif expressed optimism regarding the ceasefire during a speech on Saturday, emphasizing that it was agreed upon for the larger interest of peace in the region. He expressed hope that ongoing disputes with India, including the contentious issue of Kashmir, would be resolved through peaceful dialogue rather than continued conflict.
Despite this positive announcement, reports from the region indicated that explosions were heard shortly after the agreement, particularly in the major cities of Srinagar and Jammu, which are located in Indian-controlled Kashmir. These blasts were followed by power outages, although there were no immediate reports of casualties. Omar Abdullah, the region’s top elected official, took to social media to express his disbelief, stating, "What the hell just happened to the ceasefire? Explosions heard across Srinagar!!!" His comments reflect widespread concern about the sincerity and feasibility of the ceasefire agreement.
Historically, the relationship between India and Pakistan has been fraught with hostility, with both nations engaging in multiple wars and skirmishes since they gained independence from British rule in 1947. The recent ceasefire followed a particularly intense period of military actions, where both countries had launched missile strikes at each other's military installations.
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Vice President JD Vance revealed that they had engaged with senior officials from both countries in the days leading up to the ceasefire. They included discussions with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Prime Minister Sharif, India's External Affairs Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, and the Pakistani Chief of Army Staff Asim Munir. The discussions culminated in an agreement to initiate talks on a broader set of issues at a neutral site.
As reports of the ceasefire spread, many Pakistanis expressed joy over the agreement. Zubaida Bibi, a resident of Islamabad, shared her relief, stating, "War brings nothing but suffering. We are happy that calm is returning. It feels like Eid to me. We have won." This sentiment of relief was echoed across various communities, signifying a collective desire for peace after the days of tension.
However, the ceasefire came in the aftermath of significant military exchanges. Just before the agreement, India had reported that its forces had targeted Pakistani air bases in retaliation for missile strikes that Pakistan had launched against critical infrastructure in India’s Punjab state. Pakistani military officials stated that they responded with strikes using medium-range Fateh missiles aimed at Indian missile storage facilities and air bases.
As the explosions rattled the region of Jammu and Kashmir post-agreement, residents expressed their fear and uncertainty. Shesh Paul Vaid, a former police chief in the area, noted that the explosions felt different from those heard during the recent drone attacks, indicating an escalation of military activities. This sentiment was shared by citizens like Mohammed Yasin, who recounted how the blasts disturbed his family’s peace, stating, "I was already awake, but the explosions jolted my kids out of their sleep. They started crying."
With both sides now entrenched in accusations and counter-accusations, the future of the ceasefire remains uncertain. Omar Abdullah remarked that had the ceasefire been negotiated a few days earlier, many lives could have been saved, showcasing the tragic consequences of delayed diplomacy.
Aaliyah Carter
Source of the news: NPR